Being a year behind the curve and all, I’m not sure there’s much I can say about ef - a tale of memories that hasn’t already been said. But I’ll say it anyway.
Previously, I described the series as “fascinating, but absolutely boring”. I got part of it right, at least. The show is indeed fascinating, both from a presentation and material standpoint. I don’t think there’s any denying that. For some, it might have been a little too fascinating - the SHAFT style doesn’t tickle everyone’s fancy, obviously - but, it was something special and unique nonetheless. For that alone, it commands attention.
Was the show really all that boring, though? No, not really. Or, to take a more nuanced approach, I found it boring before I found it not boring. I voted against it before I voted for it. In other words, on my first attempt at watching the series when it first aired a year ago, I was indeed bored with. Upon my second attempt a year later, I was enthralled. What happened?
The simple answer, I think, is that, whereas I was stuck following the show on a weekly basis like most everyone else the first time around, I marathoned it over the course of only a few days the second. There’s an ebb and flow in the pace of the show that wasn’t particularly evident when I was watching it in half hour chunks once a week; this ebb and flow is painfully obvious, however, when the entirety of the show is watched in short order. A series of climaxes, breakdowns, and hairpin turns, it was a hell of a ride once I surrendered myself to the show’s pace. I’ve always felt that not all anime is meant to be watched in the same fashion, and my experience with ef - a tale of memories clearly supports that philosophy.
Mea culpa aside, what of the show’s content? All in all, the story (or stories, I suppose) isn’t all that original as far as visual novel adaptations go. There are some unique elements - Chihiro’s illness, for example - and those elements are treated more thoughtfully and carefully than one would expect, but as far as the core story goes, it’s been done before. The direction and production made all the difference in the world, however. It took what was, in many ways, a generic story and turned it into something remarkably compelling. The love triangle storyline, for example, was essentially every love triangle storyline I’ve seen before (I kept having flashbacks to Kiminozo at the most inopportune moments). And Chihiro’s storyline was little more than the typical “girl with a mystery” tragedy that are a dime a dozen in the medium.
Yet, the anime adaptation was remarkable. I’d be curious to know how the original game was received, given that it didn’t benefit from the same treatment as the anime series. It’s worth noting how anime fans often pan adaptations that stray too far from their original material. And with good reason. For example, much of the strength of the recent Key visual novel adaptations lies in Kyoto Animation’s reliance on and militant devotion to the original storylines and narratives. And the anime adaptations of popular manga series that most often get high marks are those that stick to the predetermined gameplan. Not all anime is cut from the same cloth, however, and there are indeed instances in which “different” is good. Sometimes, it’s just a matter of a different approach casting something in a pleasing light. Sometimes, it’s a matter of casting something in a better and more positive light. Sometimes, it’s a matter of saving something from itself.
I think ef - a tale of memories is the perfect example of each and every one of those outcomes. It could have been nothing special. Should of been. But, it wasn’t. Chalk one up for anime, eh?
Ever since giving up on the series way back when, I wrestled with the question of whether or not I gave it a raw deal. I always try to give any anime series that catches my eye a fair shake, and when something I’ve dropped turns out to impress people I know to have a similar eye for anime as I do, as was the case with ef - a tale of memories, I can’t help but try again. And with the second season of the series looming, the timing couldn’t have been any better. Of course, I now face a rather curious predicament: do I dive into the second season a month from now and risk tripping to a “fascinating, but absolutely boring” conclusion once again, or do I have patience and set aside a weekend in the future in which to down the series in one fell swoop?
Tough call. It’s a mighty fine predicament to be in, though.
