Slumber Party

I’m really not much of a Type-Moon fan. I’ll give the studio credit for finding success, but as far as their works are concerned, I’ve never been all that impressed.

And while I understand Type-Moon’s popularity in Japan, I’m often perplexed by the studio’s apparent popularity here in North America. Let’s be honest: how many non-Japanese Type-Moon fanboys have actually played the studio’s games? And, of those who have, how many actually understood what the hell was going on? After all, unless one’s Japanese reading skills are well developed, even the simplest bishoujo game can be extremely difficult to follow. As for a Type-Moon game? You might as well be reading the manual to the Space Shuttle. In pig latin.

So, for those of us not well-versed in crazy moon language, our acquaintance with Type-Moon is made through its games’ anime adaptations. Do those impress?

Yes and no. The Tsukihime TV series is generally regarded as a disappointment - an attractive disappointment, but a disappointment nonetheless. Despite high hopes, I was far from impressed with how the show turned out. It was almost enough to put me off Type-Moon from there on out. But, it was just a matter of time before Fate/Stay Night (and its associated hype machine) came along, bringing promise of redemption. Obviously, I had to watch. And?

It’s better than Tsukihime, at least.

The show definitely gets things right in the production department. The animation is extremely detailed, and the character designs are easy on the eyes. On the other hand, the action sequences (which are no small part of the show) aren’t particularly flashy. This actually came as a surprise. I suppose it’s less a question of budget and more a matter of direction. Regardless, I expected better than grunting, speed lines, and close-ups - at least in the early episodes.

Kenji Kawai’s score is really something, though, and perhaps my favorite element of the show thus far. I especially enjoy his take on the OP, which gets the old school fan within me crying tears of joy. And, thankfully, the voice acting thus far is superb. They really pulled together a talented cast. It’s worth noting, however, that I only hear Asa-sempai when Fujimura-sensei opens her mouth. I can’t shake it.

As for the story? Well, it’s Type-Moon. In other words, it’s ten times more complicated than it needs to be. And, unfortunately, the pacing is clunky to match. It’s nowhere near as dull as Tsukihime, that’s for sure, but it’s still a chore to watch in spots. I’m not expecting wall-to-wall action, mind you (that would probably be worse, actually), but when the story is so dense that the first few episodes are half exposition, you’ve got a problem. I suspect I’ll enjoy the show more once it settles into a groove. For the time being, however, I watch with bemused detachment.

Still, it’s all good. Rin is hot, after all.

3 Responses to “Slumber Party”


  1. 1 mangamaxx

    Really? I really enjoy the type moon stuff. I’ve only played the fighting game version of their stuff, but I read translations on the rest. I can understand what you’re saying though, type-moon’s strength is also it’s weakness. They really go in-depth with there stories and create their own unique world which is impressive, but on the other hand it means a lot of reading to get up to date on what’s going on. I do enjoy Fate/Stay Night much more than tsukihime just cause of all the mythological references alone and I feel it makes it more worth it to read the prologues for it. Course I may be biased, I’m Asian, could it be an Asian thing? I mean i really enjoy series like Fate because of all the research that’s done for it. Well I’ve read all the endings for Fate, and while they’re all incredible story-wise, none of them delivers that happy ending I wanted. The same goes for Tsukihime. I thought the story was great, but it left me with a little void inside and it wasn’t because of a lack of an ending. It was more like a “like isn’t fair” feeling, and that’s true so I guess I’ll have to accept that.

  2. 2 Saria

    I’m not really into the series myself. The sheer amount of hype was enough to get me downloading, but I don’t know if I’ll continue watching or blogging. I do notice, however, that my traffic skyrockets whenever I blog a new episode. People are absolutely obsessed with this show, even if my reviews are mostly negative. And I have already gotten a lot of flack for totally dissing the protagonist. But hey. You like what you like, right? Tsukihime didn’t grasp me at all and my borrowed fansubs are collecting dust in the corner of my desk.

  3. 3 Joe

    I realize this post is two years old, and you may or may not have finished the series…

    But the show is only slow up to the halfway point. It picks up and moves very quickly after that.

    And to the above poster, Shirou is a total loser in this particular story arc. The original story had 3 story arcs, and he’s gar in the other two. Even more so in the third one. Trust me, Shirou is much better of a character beyond the anime.

Comments are currently closed.